ClientEarth's 10 November page files a Commission complaint over Croatia's community-energy rules - H-Alter the same day prints a 500 kW surplus line and a HERA form still unpublished, a consolidated Article 51 prints 0.9 and 500 kW, and storage is named with no kilowatt-hours
On 10 November 2026 ClientEarth said it filed complaints with the European Commission against Bulgaria and Croatia over renewable energy communities. The Croatia lines print three registered citizen energy communities and no megawatts. H-Alter the same day prints a 28 February 2026 registration deadline, a HERA form still unpublished, a SAVA application from February still waiting, about 40% of shareable electricity passed on in Rijeka in July, and a 500 kW line it attributes to the renewable-energy law. A consolidated reading of Article 51 prints that 500 kW cap on the supplier's duty to take surplus, and a 0.9 factor on one surplus formula. Article 26 names storage for a citizen energy community and prints no kilowatt-hours.
A small firm in Croatia can share a roof with its neighbours. The paperwork for that share, and the price of the leftover noon power, are two different pages. Neither page prints a battery size.
ClientEarth's page is dated 10 November 2026. It says the organisation filed complaints with the European Commission against Bulgaria and Croatia. The complaints follow filings against Poland and Hungary in July. The page says that makes four countries. It says EU countries were required to put the Renewable Energy Directive into practice by 30 June 2021. The Croatia section says the current rules make it hard for energy communities to stay afloat. It quotes Goran Čačić, president of the Zagreb-based ZEZ Green Energy Cooperative: three officially registered citizen energy communities, one most likely already out of commission, and two struggling to make a living without a proper business model or support. The page does not name the three. It does not print a kilowatt, a kilowatt-hour, or a euro rate for a Croatian meter.
The same page prints up to €930 a year for households in energy communities that use a mix of solar and wind. Footnote 8 points that line at a Commission communication of 10 March 2026. The figure is an EU household line. It is not a Croatian shop bill, and the page does not print the bill it was measured against. A school roof and an apartment roof are the examples. A workplace battery is not one of them. Bulgaria is described as a leader in battery storage. The Croatia paragraphs do not pick up that sentence.
H-Alter, also dated 10 November 2026, carries the same complaint and adds the filing detail. It says existing renewable energy communities had until 28 February 2026 to apply for registration, and that HERA has still not published the application form. Energetska zajednica SAVA filed in February and is still waiting. H-Alter quotes a SAVA representative: approval to start has not arrived, the form was not on HERA's website when the application went in, and a later request to add to the file is expected and has not arrived. This note did not open HERA's website. The unpublished form is H-Alter's account on 10 November.
H-Alter also prints a 500 kW line and attributes it to the Croatian renewable-energy law. Suppliers take surplus from eligible projects only when members' total connection for sending power into the grid is 500 kW or under. The page says ClientEarth's view is that the threshold can make it harder to bring in local firms with larger roofs. In Rijeka, Energetska zajednica Sjevernog Jadrana passed on only about 40% of the electricity available for sharing in July. The page does not print the year on that July. Each member had a fixed share, so the split did not move as use changed through the day. The community has since worked with the regulator, the network operator and suppliers on a more flexible approach. H-Alter repeats the three-community line. SAVA is printed as an applicant still waiting, not as one of the three. The page does not add those into a fourth count.
The consolidated text of Article 51, on the Lexium reading of the renewable-energy law, is the surplus rule H-Alter is pointing at. Paragraph 1 prints a duty on suppliers to take surplus from customers with their own production, or from users of a self-supply plant, when several conditions are met together. Point 4 is the community line: total export connection power at the meters of the members of a renewable energy community is not greater than total import connection power at those meters, and not more than 500 kW. Points 2 and 3 print their own 500 kW caps, for a single customer and for renewable consumers acting together. The duty is the whole list. A roof whose export connection sits above 500 kW is outside that duty on this page. The page does not print a named workplace that has crossed it.
The price, when the duty applies. Paragraph 5 is the formula for a customer with their own production. Ci equals 0.9 times PKCi when energy taken from the grid is at least energy sent back. Ci equals 0.9 times PKCi times Epi divided by Eii when energy sent back is larger. PKCi is the average energy price that customer pays the supplier, excluding the network part and other regulated add-ons, in euro per kilowatt-hour. The page does not print a sample PKCi and does not print a sample bill. 0.9 is nine tenths. A month that sends back twice what it takes uses one half inside that formula, our arithmetic, and 0.9 times one half is 0.45. The page does not print 0.45. Paragraph 7 is a different formula, for a self-supply user. It uses a factor called kSO. The page says that factor is set in a later incentive framework and cannot be greater than 1. It does not print the number in force. Paragraph 16 says the provisions for self-supply users and for customers with their own production also apply to shareholders and members of a renewable energy community. A community meter can sit on either formula. This page does not say which.
Storage sits on a different statute. Article 26 of the electricity-market law, again on the Lexium consolidated reading, is the citizen energy community. Paragraph 11 says the community may store energy for its members. Paragraph 15 says it may arrange sharing from its production plants and from its storage plants. Paragraph 21 says total export connection power at members' meters is not greater than total import connection power. That paragraph does not print 500 kW. Paragraph 22 says surplus that is not used in the sharing is taken by the supplier at the member's meter. It does not print 0.9 and it does not print a euro rate. Paragraph 4 prints a 40% ownership cap: a member does not hold more than 40% of another member. That 40% is ownership. H-Alter's about 40% in Rijeka is a share of electricity. The two pages are not the same 40. Paragraph 3 says actual control stays with members who are not medium or large enterprises, and that voting is one member, one vote. Paragraph 2 says a member may be a natural or legal person, including a local government unit, a micro enterprise or a small enterprise.
No workplace battery is sized on any of these pages. No solar kilowatts are printed for a named roof. No cent rate for a Croatian firm is printed. The €930 line stays on the Commission communication ClientEarth cites. The surplus credit on Article 51 sits inside that list, including the 500 kW export connection, and the meter then sits on one of the two formulas.
Analogy: 500 kW is how hard the shared roof can press power back into the grid and still sit inside the supplier's duty to take the surplus. A kilowatt-hour is how far that power ran. Article 26 names a storage tank beside the panels and prints no litres.
Good: A 10 November complaint page, a same-day Croatian report with the February deadline and the missing form, a consolidated Article 51 that still prints 500 kW and the 0.9 formula, and an Article 26 that names storage without pretending to size it.
Bad: The three communities are unnamed. SAVA's wait is H-Alter's account, and this note did not open HERA's site. July in Rijeka has no year and no kilowatt-hours. The 0.45 line is our arithmetic on the formula. kSO is capped at 1 and not printed. Lexium is a consolidated reading, not a gazette PDF opened for this note. The €930 figure is an EU household line from a March communication.
Ugly: Pasting €930 onto a Croatian shop bill. Treating 500 kW as a ban on a larger roof, rather than the edge of the supplier's duty on Article 51. Treating Article 26's export limit as the same 500 kW. Mixing the ownership 40% with Rijeka's energy 40%. Inventing a community battery in kilowatt-hours.
Soft next step: write the supplier's surplus duty as a 500 kW line on the consolidated article, keep the 0.9 factor on the own-production formula, and leave a community battery's kilowatt-hours blank.
Source: ClientEarth, 10 Nov 2026, complaints against Bulgaria and Croatia. Primary for the 10 November 2026 filings, the July complaints against Poland and Hungary, the 30 June 2021 directive deadline, three registered citizen energy communities in Croatia on the quoted lines, and up to €930 a year for households in communities using solar and wind, footnoted to a Commission communication of 10 March 2026. The Croatia section prints no kilowatts and no battery. H-Alter, 10 Nov 2026, the Croatian complaint. Primary for the 28 February 2026 registration deadline, a HERA form still unpublished, SAVA's February application still waiting, about 40% of shareable electricity passed on in Rijeka in July with no year printed, and the 500 kW surplus line attributed to the renewable-energy law. Lexium, consolidated Article 51, renewable-energy law. Primary for the supplier's duty, the 500 kW caps in points 2, 3 and 4, the 0.9 formula in paragraph 5, kSO capped at 1 in paragraph 7, and paragraph 16 applying those provisions to community members. 0.9 times one half is 0.45, our arithmetic. The page does not print 0.45. Lexium, consolidated Article 26, electricity-market law. Primary for storage and sharing from storage plants, the export-connection limit with no 500 kW, the 40% ownership cap, and one member, one vote. No kilowatt-hours are printed.